Take a Walk Down a Vampire-Filled Memory Lane with Our Top 50 True Blood Moments

10. Sookie Dreams About Eric and Bill

Who says you can’t have it all? When Sookie has a dream about having both Bill and Eric in her life, at the same time, no less, fans went nuts. Sookie reasons that there’s no reason she has to choose between her vampire lovers. Instead, she muses, they can simply share her.

In her dream, Sookie speaks to Bill and Eric and tells them that she can’t make up her mind, and they’re just going to have to share her. The trio exchanges some passionate kisses on her couch. (By this point Anna Paquin and Stephen Moyer were already married, so seeing them with Alexander Skarsgaard in a heated sex scene is kind of funny.) However, Sookie has no idea how challenging it would be to maintain such a relationship, and deep down she knows that eventually she’ll have to make a choice.

Over seven seasons Sookie has relationships with Bill, Sam, Eric and Alcide. That’s pretty good for the girl who had her first boyfriend in the first season.