Skip to main content

Nocturne season 1 episode 5 recap: An ugly truth

Saga gets closer to Walter and his plan in Nocturne season 1 episode 5.
ByMatthew Fox
Stephen Graham in "Nocturne," now streaming on Apple TV.
Stephen Graham in "Nocturne," now streaming on Apple TV. | Credit: Apple TV

When you know something with all your heart and you can’t prove it, the frustration mounts. That’s even more the case when you’re an investigator chasing a dangerous criminal. It can be tempting to take a shortcut, but what happens if you do?

At the end of Nocturne season 1 episode 4, Jurek Walter (Stephen Graham) made a bold claim that Jonah (Liev Schreiber) planted his DNA. That would have been the basis for his conviction and being sent to the facility. But is it true? In season 1 episode 5, “Solitude,” tackles that head on. Let’s dive in.

No admission

We begin with a flashback. A desperate Jonah is pushing Walter on his job site. Walter is smug, and he’s guilty, but there is no evidence. Jonah knows he’s the guy, but he can’t prove it. And Walter rubs his nose in it before getting back to work. That leads to Jonah scooping up some spit off the ground and tucking it away.

Back in the present, Agent Quinn (Poorna Jagannathan) pushes Jonah for the truth of why Walter sent the note. He remains silent. She tells him to share what he knows or leave the team. Jonah opts to walk out. Chief Ellison (Bill Camp) protests it’s a mistake, but Quinn wants answers. She won’t trust Jonah without the truth.

Ellison follows Jonah out. He tries to urge him to be forthcoming and not to give up. He claims it was him who made the mistake directing the investigation. But Jonah holds himself responsible for his shortcomings — all of them. And he’s committed to making sure Walter doesn’t use it to escape justice. Not this time.

So, he continues to pursue the truth. That leads him to the woods and the burial site for a couple of dogs. They were long buried in the ground, left to die like Walter’s victims. He follows the trail back to their owner — but finds something unexpected. The dogs’ original owner is dead. He lost his will to live after his dogs were taken.

That sparks something for Jonah. Perhaps it’s not the people who were taken, but the effect of their disappearance on others. For every victim who was taken, someone close to them gave up and took their own life, everyone except Michael and Felicia’s mother — Ida (Chrissy Metz).

Rough adjustment

Chrissy Metz in Nocturne
Chrissy Metz in Nocturne | Dennis P. Mong Jr

Michael (Landon Valentin) has been allowed to return home, but it’s hard to adjust. He prefers dark and tight spaces. He isn’t comfortable anywhere, even when Ida tries to take him out to the diner for lunch. He ends up eating his food in a dark storage closet. Ida worries that she’s not doing enough for her son.

She’s also unaware of the developments in the case or the fact that Quinn wants to find her. But she sees Michael in her closet, wanting to play a game. It’s a game of hangman, and he says it’s on behalf of the Sandman. At first, she resists, but Ida decides it’s the best thing to help Michael. The puzzle is her name. She asks what it means. Michael draws a hung man and says that if she fulfills the role, Felicia will be allowed to return home.

Close to a monster

Meanwhile, Saga (Zazie Beetz) has accomplished her mission of going into special holding. She’s in the cell next to Walter. She makes something of a connection with Karl (Rory Culkin), who doesn’t realize he’s being used by the police to establish the bonafides for Saga with Walter. But it doesn’t take long for Walter to become intrigued by his neighbor.

It also doesn’t take long for Saga to realize she can hear Walter. He talks to her, the way we saw him talk to his last neighbor. He’s trying to manipulate her, but she’s manipulating him, too. So, Saga makes a push to get information and, by the end of the episode, has a clue — Hopewell River Gorge. The information gets to Jonah, who hopes it’s the key to finding Felicia alive before anything worse happens.


This was a solid episode of Nocturne. We get the answer that Jonah cheated to get Walter the first time and will likely have to torch his reputation before this journey ends. We also moved closer to uncovering the real plan. It’s not about the people their loss impacts. What does that mean for Ida, and how will it lead to the Sandman? That’s a question we have a few episodes left to discover.

Nocturne streams Fridays on Apple TV. Check back next week as we recap all the action of the season right here.

Add us as a preferred source on Google