Skip to main content

Phony season 1 episode 6 recap: Sonny takes a big risk to prove his theory

Determined to prove his sister-switch theory, Sonny goes rogue to try and find his real mom — but the outcome is devastating.
ByMarissa Messiano
Disney/David Astorga

We finally have a major lead in the mystery, even though the details aren't quite adding up. In Phony episode 5, Sonny puts the pieces together from his mom's journals and Sharla's sleuthing, and he realizes that his mom had an estranged sister named Tracy.

The theory the show is presenting is that Tracy was able to fully take over Ellen's life, but there are obvious differences in their appearance, and the show has made it very clear that no one else in town thinks Ellen's face has changed.

So if we're running with this theory, how was Tracy able to get rid of Ellen and study her life? How did she learn to be the school principal? How did she switch out so many photos and not raise any suspicion among coworkers and other students? It doesn't quite add up. So if this is Tracy pretending to be Ellen, are there still supernatural elements at play? Here's what we learned about the Imposter Sister Tracy theory in Phony season 1 episode 6, titled "I'm Right Here."

Sonny goes on a dangerous search for answers

After his huge lightbulb moment, an electric Sonny races off to Sharla's house with his friend Vogel to discuss what's next. Weldon and Mallory are already there, and the group needs some convincing to get behind the Tracy sister theory. In his high-energy panic, Sonny reveals that he may have already called the cops on Tracy, making Sharla realize that she needs to keep him in line so that he doesn't get himself further into trouble with his mom.

And yes, a police officer does meet with Ellen/Tracy at the school, but the cop obviously doesn't believe him, and Sharla warns Sonny that this is only going to lead to Ellen/Tracy getting the upper hand and convincing the police that Sonny's having a mental health episode. At the speed Sonny's moving, Sharla knows no one will take him seriously. Defying Sharla's recommendation, Sonny gets his friends in the van, and they head out to investigate Tracy's house.

Weldon texts Sharla about Sonny going rogue — for safety reasons (he's not a rat) — and she warns him that Tracy has a criminal record and that confronting her could be dangerous. Weldon tries to stall, but Sonny is steadfast on sticking to his plan. But when they get to the house, Weldon is at least able to convince Sonny to stay in the car, and Vogel volunteers to knock on the door.

Phony episode 5.
Disney

Who does Sonny find living at Tracy's house?

As Vogel gets to the door, a man (who we later learned is named Eric) walks up behind him, and Sonny recognizes him as the man who Ellen/Tracy paid in the parking lot! Sonny races out of the car, and Mallory and Weldon follow behind him, trying to get him to back down. Sonny confronts Eric and demands to know where Ellen and Tracy are, and to Sonny's surprise, Eric stays calm and addresses Sonny by name. Sonny says the group is going to stay until Tracy gets home, and Eric actually welcomes them to wait in the house.

But waiting isn't good enough for Sonny, and he sneaks upstairs to look for his mom. Eric makes an excuse to leave the room and of course calls Ellen/Tracy at work. When she learns Sonny is at the house, she bolts out of the principal's office. Upstairs, Sonny finds abandoned medical equipment, storage boxes and two old suitcases, but doesn't find any signs of the real Ellen. And when Tracy (still pretending to be Ellen) arrives at the house, she expects the kids to still believe she's Sonny's mom. And honestly, she could be! Parts of this story still aren't totally clicking, and there has to be more to this mystery!

CONNIE BRITTON
Disney

The estranged sister Tracy theory comes crashing down

Sonny thought he had everything figured out, but five seconds later, the REAL Tracy walks through the door, and she looks absolutely nothing like Ellen. Sonny's whole theory about his mom being replaced by his sister falls apart, and Sonny is devastated to be wrong. Ellen confirms that Tracy did break into their house, but all of the conflict stems from the siblings fighting over inheritance, which is the money Ellen paid Eric in the parking lot.

In the final moments of the episode, Ellen gets emotional as she pleads with Sonny to see that his mom is sitting right there with him. She's terrified of how he's been acting, and she's so afraid to lose him too. We don't fully learn what Sonny is thinking as he listens to Ellen fight for their relationship, but Sonny does a complete 180 from how he's been treating Ellen and tells her that he needs psychological help.

New episodes of Phony air Tuesdays on Hulu and with Hulu on Disney+.

Add us as a preferred source on Google