Why we're still thinking about Our Flag Means Death months after its cancellation

Here are 5 reasons why the show continues to stay in our minds and our hearts.
Nicola Dove/Max
Nicola Dove/Max /

Our Flag Means Death was far more than an ordinary pirate story. It was a unique mix of comedy, romance, and adventure that won over a lot of people. Fans ended up with a void that hasn't gone away months after Max said it would end after two seasons. The series was canceled in January 2024, and did not deserve it. Let's look into the five reasons why this show continues to stay in our minds and our hearts.

A unique blend of comedy and romance

One thing that made the swashbuckling tale stand out was how well it mixed comedy and a touching love story. The show was about Stede Bonnet, a gentleman-turned-pirate, and his strange friendship with Blackbeard, the famous pirate. This unusual pair's journey was a new take on the pirate theme, with both humorous and touching scenes.

The segment where Stede and Blackbeard speak under the moonlight on the deck of their ship is a great example of this delicate balance. The scene starts off funny, but as they talk about their worries and hopes, it slowly turns into a touching moment of vulnerability. It's a great example of how the drama could make people tear up and chuckle in the same scene.

Our Flag Means Death Image by Nicola Dove
Nicola Dove/Max /

The cast's chemistry

The actors had great chemistry with each other, which made their exchanges more real and interesting. They brought their characters to life with so much grace and humor that it was hard not to root for them. Rhys Darby played Stede Bonnet and Taika Waititi played Blackbeard. The supporting cast, which was full of strange and memorable people, was also very important in making the world feel both amazing and real.

For instance, the cast members' friendship, shown through Frenchie's (Joel Fry) funny songs and Oluwande's (Samson Kayo) insightful words, made the story more interesting. Each of the characters brought something different to the show, which made the interactions feel real and added to the its charm as a whole.

Creative storytelling

David Jenkins, who created the series, was able to craft a story that was both interesting and difficult to predict. The show stood out in a crowded market because it mixed historical aspects with current ideas. The story was brave and it often went against common pirate tropes to give audiences something completely fresh.

The episode in which Stede and his crew go to a lavish party and laughably feel out of place is a great example of this kind of creative writing. This episode successfully turned the standard pirate story on its head by putting the characters in a place that was very different from where they usually were. This made their peculiarities and traits stand out in a new way.

Our Flag Means Death Image by Nicola Dove
Nicola Dove/Max /

Unresolved plotlines

The very tense finish of Our Flag Means Death season 2 is one reason why fans continue to talk about the show. Many loose ends in the story made people eager to see how it would all come together. There was a sense of unfinished business after the cancellation, which led to frustration and fan ideas and talks about what could have been.

In the last episode of the last season, Stede and Blackbeard decided to stop piracy and run an inn jointly while their crew went on exciting new adventures. A lot of things remained unresolved by the ending, like what happened to their friendship and what would happen to the rest of the crew. Viewers are still wondering what might have happened next in these stories.

Fan campaigns and community

According to EW, the Our Flag Means Death fan group has been very active, running campaigns to bring back the show and keeping the talk going on social media. It's clear from these actions that fans care deeply about the show and want it to keep going. The pirate drama has been very important to the community, as shown by their excitement. These fans' unwavering commitment shows how much the television series has affected them, creating a sense of community and a love for the special world.

In conclusion, Our Flag Means Death was far more than just a television show. It was a shining example of creativity, and sharing stories from the heart. Its ending left a hole that numerous supporters, including myself, feel very deeply. We keep thinking about Stede and Blackbeard's adventures, which makes us remember the show's unique appeal and how it changed people's lives. Because of these, and numerous other reasons, the compelling series is still talked about and remembered by many.

Seasons 1 and 2 of Our Flag Means Death are currently streaming on Max.

Next. The best (and worst) shows to stream on Max. The best (and worst) shows to stream on Max. dark